Honest comparison

Setlist vs Set List Maker

A shared modern band workspace compared with a mature personal performance database.

The short answer

Choose Setlist for an actively shared band workspace with a lightweight learning curve. Existing Set List Maker users with a tuned MIDI or performance setup may reasonably keep it; its developer announced a feature freeze and points users needing ongoing cloud collaboration toward BandHelper.

Side by side

What you needSetlistSet List Maker

Shared band workspaceBuilt around band membershipPrimarily device/database based

Setlist and song databaseSimple shared modelMature personal database

MIDI and performance automationNot the primary focusEstablished feature set

Current product directionActive native and web developmentFeature-frozen by its developer

Migration and setupBest for a clean, focused startExisting setups may be valuable to retain

Choose Setlist if…

You are setting up a band-wide shared system now.
You want gigs, invites, repertoire and setlists connected.
You value a simpler workflow over deep stage automation.

Choose Set List Maker if…

You already have a reliable Set List Maker database and live setup.
MIDI, backing tracks or performance layouts are central to your show.
You do not need an actively evolving collaboration product.

Competitor capabilities were checked against the Set List Maker developer announcement. Product features change; verify any requirement that is critical to your show.

Want the focused option?

Setlist is coming first to iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch.

Join the iOS beta

All comparisons